Get 20% off the new Gentleman’s Journal Clubhouse membership. Limited time only.

Is it ever acceptable to propose at Christmas?

Under the mistletoe, down on one knee — is a tinsel-trimmed proposal ever a good idea?

The twinkling lights. The falling snow. The gift giving. Christmas is undoubtedly one of the most romantic times of the year — and we haven’t even started on the Baileys yet. But there is a dangerous side to all of this merry-making: Research shows, year after year, that Christmas is the most popular time for proposals.

Proposals aren’t dangerous, we hear you cry! True. But, before you shout ‘Scrooge!’ and get down on one knee anyway, maybe take a moment to think. Are you proposing because you’re ready, really in love and the timing is just magically, monumentally right? Or has that third glass of wine and the fact you’ve just successfully cooked a massive turkey got you riding a confident Christmas high?

If it’s the latter, it’s time to press pause. Snap shut that ring box and have a read of our top tips for festive proposals. That way, even if you’re dead set on taking the plunge between carolling and Christmas dinner, you won’t wake up on Boxing Day with any regrets…

Step away from the drinks cabinet: Are you sober?

We’ve all been guilty of over-generosity after that sixth or seventh drink, haven’t we? And, if you have a track record of drunken rashness, the Christmas cocktails — we’re looking at you, Snowballs — are likely to make you even more likely to get down on one knee. Remember, it’s harder to backtrack on ‘will you marry me’ than ‘I’ll get the next round’. Especially if she’s already shared the news on Instagram…

Our advice? Steer clear of the booze altogether if you’re planning to hide a ring box in her stocking. Coast through Christmas on festive joy alone and seriously consider saving your proposal for a sober, memorable day in the New Year.

Does she really want her family there?

Another thing about Christmas: it’s not very private. If your bride-to-be, for some reason, decides she doesn’t want to tie the knot with you — you don’t want to be popping the question in front of Uncle Geoff. That’s an unsalvageable situation. You’re better off getting that perfume she originally hinted at — and not risking the red faces.

Even if you do get the answer you were hoping for, you’ll steal all of those moments in which she wanted to surprise her family with the flash of a new diamond ring. Because, somewhere in the room, there’ll be a tech-savvy cousin who’s a fiend for social media — and your big news will be broken before you can say ‘Facebook Live’.

Am I doing this because I didn’t get her a gift?

Every year, we feel the pressure to top the gifts we gave the year before. It can be stifling. But, while many resort to holidays or sports cars in answering the dreaded, annual instruction of ‘surprise me’, it can sometimes drive a gentleman to desperate measures.

In a nutshell, if the big day creeps up on you from the depths of December — and you’ve not yet planned a gift — do NOT attempt to solve that oversight by getting down on one knee. You’d be better off hoying the brandy bottle into your Christmas tree and setting the whole thing alight*.

*Other, less fiery options include: rescheduling the exchange of gifts; booking a city break for early next year; bagging a bargain for her in the Boxing Day sales.

Am I just doing this because it’s Christmas?

Forget rose-tinted glasses — Christmas is more like a pair of month-long, high-strength beer goggles, covering everything in a saccharine-sweet, candy-coated film. You’re not in work, you’re never completely sober and there’s an awful lot of cuddling in front of the fire watching heartfelt nonsense on TV.

The temptation to luxuriate, overindulge and make reckless romantic decisions in this seasonal limbo will be tempting. But try to edge back from taking the leap — when January rears its wintry head the drop may look a lot more risky.

Am I doing this to cure my S.A.D?

The weather outside may be frightful, and have us going all kinds of crazy to keep our spirits up (what’s cracker-pulling all about, really?) but, eventually, the cold air will warm and the dark days will brighten.

So, even though proposing may seem like a good way to bring cheer to winter, a sunny spring day really isn’t that far away.

And trust us, she’ll be grateful if you wait. Spring will bring a more photogenic natural light for the obligatory ring snap, lighter nights for your engagement party, and fewer people behind-your-back whispering: “a Christmas proposal? How cliche…”

Still going ahead with it? Alright, then – read our guide to popping the question at Christmas...

Become a Gentleman’s Journal member. Find out more here.

Become a Gentleman’s Journal Member?

Become a Gentleman’s Journal Member?

Like the Gentleman’s Journal? Why not join the Clubhouse, a special kind of private club where members receive offers and experiences from hand-picked, premium brands. You will also receive invites to exclusive events, the quarterly print magazine delivered directly to your door and your own membership card.

Click here to find out more

Further reading